Experimental Analysis of the Mechanics of Sport Climbing Falls

Nico F. Schad

Department of Mechanical Engineering, Box-870276, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL-35487, USA.

Yannick F. Schad

Department of Mathematics, Box-870350, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL-35487, USA.

Chip Garret

LPC-S Counseling and Consultation LLC, 303 Hargrove Road, Suite A, Tuscaloosa, AL-35401, USA.

Alex Voris

Department of Mechanical Engineering, Box-870276, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL-35487, USA.

Heike Schad

The Capitol School, 2828 6th St., Tuscaloosa, AL 35401, USA.

Rainer Schad *

Department of Physics and Astronomy, Box 870324, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL-35487, USA.

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.


Abstract

Rock climbing falls can be safely stopped and are often a routine part of the sport. However, safety may be compromised not only by equipment failure but also due to the climbers’ misjudgment of the situation. Current literature and other resources are either based on laboratory experiments or lacking specific and systematic measurements of the relevant parameters of lead climber falls. Only one recent theoretical paper describes the physics of lead climber falls under realistic conditions. To provide research-based safety guidance for the climber community systematic studies of various scenarios are needed.

In this study experimental data were collected and analyzed from lead climber falls on an actual climbing route, recording all positions prior to and after the fall as well as climber and belayer acceleration data. The data reveal the actual fall height, the forces acting on belayer and climber and the dissipation mechanisms of the fall energy. Two test series were performed, varying the fall height or the belayer mass, respectively. Substantially longer total fall heights are found, in particular for lighter belayers, even for relatively short falls. The major mechanisms to dissipate the energy are the energy losses when accelerating the belayer of the ground and the friction force in the loaded carabiner. The study concludes with recommendations for best practice under various conditions for a safe climbing experience.

Keywords: Rock climbing safety, belaying best practice, rock climbing physics, energy conservation


How to Cite

F. Schad, N., F. Schad, Y., Garret, C., Voris, A., Schad, H., & Schad, R. (2023). Experimental Analysis of the Mechanics of Sport Climbing Falls. Journal of Engineering Research and Reports, 24(2), 28–38. https://doi.org/10.9734/jerr/2023/v24i2800

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Smith RA. The development of equipment to reduce risk in rock climbing. Sports Engineering. 1998;1:27.

Huber H, Wege and Weggefährten. Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://hermannhuber.de/geschichten/

Doug Robinson - OG Yosemite Climber shares history, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b45OXWG3kzQ

The milestones at a glance in About Us, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available: https://edelrid.com/us-en/edelrid/about-us

Blackford J, Maycock E, Mountaineering Equipment - Ropes Harnesses, Karabiners and Anchors, Materials World. Special European Supplement. 2001;9(8):8-12.

Semmel C, Hellberg F, Stürze halten — sicher und sanft, DAV Panorama. 2012;3:72.

Zanantoni, C, Analysis of belaying techniques: A typical UIAA Activity, World Mountaineering and Climbing, The Journal of the UIAA. 2000;3:7-11.

Vogwell J, Minguez JM. The safety of rock climbing protection devices under falling loads, Engineering Failure Analysis. 2007;14:1114.

Fuss FK, Niegl G, Understanding the mechanics of dynamic rope brakes, Procedia Engineering. 2010;2:3323–3328.

Committed to Climber Safety: Uiaa Safety Resources, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available: https://www.theuiaa.org/safety/

UIAA: Climbing & Mountaineering Skills, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available: https://www.theuiaa.org/skills/

DAV: Sportklettern: Sichern mit Gewichtsunterschied, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.alpenverein.de/bergsport/sicherheit/klettern/sichern-mit-gewichtsunterschied_aid_29328.html

DAV: Ich hab dich?!, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.alpenverein.de/bergsport/sicherheit/klettern/ich-hab-dich_aid_32286.html

Petzl: Tech Tips, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.petzl.com/INT/en/Sport/Techniques

Boulderama TV. Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nv441b0-Esw&feature=share&fbclid=IwAR2FKcvDCKMYGj7sOjf5_0WIGb3iiHFK1JvskOAAZUnAJ1OcT7DStSkV2ZI

Rauch S, Wallner B, Ströhle M, Dal Cappello T, Brodmann Maeder M, Climbing Accidents—Prospective Data Analysis from the International Alpine Trauma Registry and Systematic Review of the Literature, Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17(1):203.

Manin L, Richard M, Brabant JD, Bissuel M, Rock Climbing Belay Device Analysis, Experiments and Modeling. In: Moritz E.F., Haake S. (eds) The Engineering of Sport 6. Springer, New York, NY; 2006.

Stronge WJ, Mathonwy T, Effectiveness of mountaineering manual belay/abseil devices, Sports Engineering. 2014;17:131–142.

Custer D, An Estimation of the Load Rate Imparted to a Climbing Anchor During Fall Arrest, The Engineering of Sport 6 (Eckehard Fozzy Moritz and Steve Haake(Eds.) Springer Science-Business Media, LLC. 2006:45-50.

Bedogni V. Computer mathematical models in belaying techniques. Proceedings of the Conference on Nylon and Ropes for Mountaineering and Caving, Torino, 8-9 March, Italy; 2002.

Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:http://personal.strath.ac.uk/andrew.mclaren/Turin2002/CD%20congresso/Computer%20mathematical%20models.pdf

Pavier M. Experimental and theoretical simulations of climbing falls Sports Engineering. 1998;1:79-91.

Leuthäusser U, The physics of a climbing rope under a heavy dynamic load, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part P: Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology. 2017;231(2):125-135.

Leuthäusser U, The mechanics of a climbing fall with a belayer who can be lifted, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part P: Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology; 2021.

DOI: 10.1177/1754337121992616

Schad R, Analysis of climbing accidents, Accident Analysis & Prevention. 2000;32(3):391-396.

Schubert P, Sicherheit und Risiko in Fels und Eis: Band 1, Bergverlag Rother GmbH; 1991.

Mägdefrau H, Anthropologischer Anzeiger. 2019;49:85.

Petzl. Forces at work in a real fall. Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.petzl.com/US/en/Sport/Forces-at-work-in-a-real-fall?ActivityName=rock-climbing

Adventure Projects Inc., Sand Rock Climbing. Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.mountainproject.com/area/105905184/sand-rock

Myriad Sensors, Inc, Pocket Lab. Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available: https://www.thepocketlab.com/

Using a value of EQ = 11 kN (elastic modulus E and rope cross section area Q); this is a realistic value given the nonlinearity of the elastic properties of climbing ropes – U. Leuthäusser, private communication.

Tan XG, Kannan R and Przekwas AJ, A comparative study of the human body finite element method under blast loadings. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2012 international mechanical engineering congress & exposition, Houston, TX, 9–15 November; 2012.

Petzl. Fall comparison with rigid/human mass, Accessed 02 January 2023.

Available:https://www.petzl.com/US/en/Sport/Fall-comparison-with-rigid-human-mass?ActivityName=rock-climbing