Process Simulation and Response Surface Optimization of the High-Pressure Reactor Section in Industrial Urea Synthesis
Ini-Obong S. Asuquo *
Centre for Gas, Refining and Petrochemicals, Institute of Petroleum Studies, School of Graduate Studies, University of Port Harcourt, Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria.
Etinyene Uko Ukpong Essien
Topfaith University Mkpatak, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Urea remains the most widely consumed nitrogen fertiliser worldwide, yet the high-pressure reactor section that governs its synthesis is frequently operated under conditions far from optimal, with attendant energy and feedstock recycling penalties. In this study, a steady-state process model of the high-pressure carbamate condenser (HPCC) and urea synthesis reactor was developed in ASPEN PLUS® 8.6, using the SR-POLAR equation of state to capture the strongly non-ideal phase and reaction equilibria of the NH₃–CO₂–NH₂COONH₄–CO(NH₂)₂–H₂O system. The validated model was coupled with a Response Surface Methodology (RSM) framework, implemented in MINITAB 18 using a central composite design, to identify the temperature and pressure that maximise conversion of ammonium carbamate to urea. Under baseline plant conditions (168°C, 143 bar), the reactor achieved only 42.5% conversion of ammonium carbamate to urea. Optimisation identified 244°C and 163.5 bar as conditions that raise conversion to 80.19%, an absolute increase of 37.69 percentage points, while the HPCC sub-model achieved a coefficient of determination (R²) of 90.4% for urea formation and 84.8% for carbamate formation; the corresponding reactor urea-yield response surface, while pointing to the same qualitative optimum, was not statistically significant at the 5% level (R² = 71.3%, P = 0.067), so the 80.19% figure should be read as indicative pending confirmation from the underlying ASPEN PLUS simulation rather than as a tightly bounded estimate. Cross-validation between the RSM-predicted yields and the independent ASPEN PLUS simulation showed reasonable agreement at the optimum (5.21% deviation) and at a nearby reference point (6.55% deviation, giving a mean absolute error of 5.88%); reconciling this reference point precisely with the plant baseline reported elsewhere in the study remains outstanding verification work. The results demonstrate that higher reactor temperature combined with moderately elevated pressure substantially improves once-through conversion, directly reducing the recycle duty, and therefore the energy penalty associated with unconverted ammonium carbamate. The validated simulation-optimisation framework provides a practical, transferable basis for retrofit and capacity-expansion decisions in urea plants, particularly within the context of fertiliser self-sufficiency programmes in developing economies such as Nigeria.
Keywords: Urea synthesis, ammonium carbamate, ASPEN PLUS, process simulation, response surface methodology, process optimisation, reactor design