Mobile Payment Applications in Countries with Low Financial Inclusion: A Multi-stakeholder Perspective Review
Stephen B. U. *
Department of Computer Engineering, University of Uyo, Nigeria.
Archibong E. E.
Department of Computer Engineering, University of Uyo, Nigeria.
Asuquo P. M.
Department of Computer Engineering, University of Uyo, Nigeria.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Aims: Mobile payment apps have become the most used mobile payment system, especially in underbanked regions. It has come be the most viable way of promoting access to and use of quality financial services, at affordable cost. As far as review works on use/adoption of mobile payment apps in low financial inclusion countries go, presentation has been from users’ perspective. Thus, under-emphasizing the challenges of other members of the m-payment app ecosystem. The work aims at describing such general challenges from the lenses of users, regulators and merchants of mobile payment apps. Also, pros and cons of some specific mobile payment apps in these regions are also provided in the work.
Place and Duration of Study: The review covered literature covering m-payment adoption in low financial inclusion countries i.e. Asian and African countries, spanning 2015 to 2023.
Methodology: In selecting the literature, we considered only journal publications considering specifically m-payment apps, and written in English. To achieve a measure of spread, major regions in the two continents were considered, and journal articles focusing on a particular country were limited to two.
Conclusion: We observe that the challenges of m-payment apps from users’ perspective are mostly denser than other perspectives. Users’ and regulators’ concerns converge only so thinly. Only regulators’ task of enlightenment of users/customer of about demonetization policies mirrors one of users’ concerns, perceived trust. Users and merchants are both concerned with perceived risk and perceived ease of use concerns. The challenges of regulators as regards m-payment apps are quite dissimilar to those of merchants. In all, the observed disparate (or thin similarity of) concerns of the different m-payment app stakeholders strengthens the need for such an inclusive review done in this work.
Keywords: M-payment app ecosystem, financial inclusion, mobile payment app
How to Cite
Downloads
References
Kumala D, Alianto H, Saputra PC, Muhammad RN. Technology acceptance model to solve mobile payment problem for SMEs. International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management Monterre. 2021:1113-1118.
Zhang L, Chao X, Qian Q, Jing F. Credit evaluation solutions for social groups with poor services in financial inclusion: A technical forecasting method. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2022; 183, 121902.
Markoska K, Ivanochko I. Mobile banking services—business information management with mobile payments. Agile Information Business; Springer: 2018:125-175.
Gupta SB, Yadav RK. Study of Growing Popularity of Payment Apps in India. Test Engineering and Management. 2020; 82: 16110-16119.
Phonthanukitithaworn C, Sellitto C, Fong MWL. A study of early adopters in Thailand. Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce.2015;20(1).
Lu L. Mobile payments—Why they are so successful? Open Journal of Business and Management. 2019; 7(3): 1131-1143.
Li´ebana-Cabanillas F, Garc´ıa-Maroto I, Mun˜oz-Leiva F, Ramos-de-Luna I. The case of apple Pay Sustainability. Mobile payment adoption in the age of digital transformation. 2020; 12(13).
Karp N. Biometrics: The future of mobile payments. US Economic Watch; BBVA Research: 2015.
Bezovski Z. The future of the mobile payment as electronic payment system. European Journal of Business and Management. 2016;8(8):127–132.
de Best, R.: Mobile Payments worldwide: Statistics and Facts [Magazine]. 2022. Accessed 2 August 2022. Available:https://www.statista.com/topics/4872/mobile-payments-worldwide/
Zafar F, Kamran A, Salman AS. Influence of e-commerce and emerging innovative technological advancements in the banking sector in Pakistan. International Conference on Management Science and Engineering Management; 2022.
Beja A. Increasing financially included population in Albania: two solutions for policymakers. The Fletcher School. 2017.
Kshetri N. The role of artificial intelligence in promoting financial inclusion in developing countries. Taylor & Francis:2021.
Loo MKL. Enhancing financial inclusion in ASEAN: Identifying the best growth markets for fintech. Journal of Risk and Financial Management. 2019; 12(4):181.
Demirgu¨¸c-Kunt A, Klapper L, Singer D, Ansar S, Hess J. The global findex database 2017: measuring financial inclusion and opportunities to expand access to and use of financial services. The World Bank Economic Review. 2020; 34:2–8.
Pesqu´e-Cela V, Tian L, Luo D, Tobin D, Kling G. Defining and measuring financial inclusion: A systematic review and confirmatory factor analysis. Journal of International Development. 2021;33(2):316-341.
Zhao J, Zhao L. Mobile payment adoption and the decline in China’s household savings rate. Empirical Economics: 2022.
Della Peruta M. Adoption of mobile money and financial inclusion: a macroeconomic approach through cluster analysis. Economics of Innovation and New Technology. 2018; 27(2):154-173.
Leng, SY, Talib A, Gunardi A. Financial technologies: A note on mobile payment. Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan. 2018;22(1):51-62.
Ahmad AH, Green C, Jiang F. Mobile money, financial inclusion and development: A review with reference to African experience. Journal of Economic Surveys. 2020; 34(4):753-792.
Joseph J, Sriram K, Rodrigues LL, Mathew AO, Gana K. An empirical study on customer adoption of mobile payment application in India. International Journal of Enterprise Network Management. 2018;9(3-4):363-375.
Ding Y, Chai KH. Emotions and continued usage of mobile applications. Industrial Management & Data Systems; 2015.
Johnson VL, Kiser A, Washington R, Torres R. Limitations to the rapid adoption of m-payment services: Understanding the impact of privacy risk on m-payment services. Computers in Human Behavior. 2018;79:111-122.
Nguyen XH, Nguyen HD, Le BTH, Tran TTM, Nguyen TMP. Factors affecting mobile payment adoption: A systematic literature review and some future research directions. International Journal of Research and Review. 2023; 10 (4):385-398
Pal A, De’ R, Herath T, Rao HR. A review of contextual factors affecting mobile payment adoption and use. Journal of Banking and Financial Technology. 2019; 3:43-57.
Sarma M. Measuring financial inclusion for Asian economies. Financial inclusion in Asia: Issues and policy concerns. 2016:3 -34.
Chen W, Yuan X. Financial inclusion in China: An overview. Frontiers of Business Research in China. 2021;15(1):1-21.
Evans M. How China Won the Race to be a Mobile-First Commerce Nation. 2017. Accessed 21 July 2023.
Sleiman KAA, Juanli L, Lei H, Liu R, Ouyang Y, Rong W. User trust levels and adoption of mobile payment systems in china: an empirical analysis. Sage Open. 2021;11(4).
R. Bodem. (2017). WeChat Pay and Offline Mobile Payments See “incredibly High” Uptake in China. 2017.
Accessed 2 August 2022. Available:https://www.nfcw.com/2017/04/26/351800/wechat-pay-offline-mobile-payments-see-incredibly-high-uptake-china/.
World Bank. World Bank Document. 2020: Accessed 2 August 2022. Available:https://openknowledge world bank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/30112/129152-BRI-PUBLIC-Brief-Chinas- Alipay-and-WeChat-Pay-Dec-2017.
Aveni T, Roest J. China’s alipay and wechat pay. CGAP:2017.
de Best R. China Alipay Vs Wechat Pay. 2021. Accessed 11 October 2022. Available:https://www.statista.com/statistics/1271130/mobile-wallet-user-forec ast-in-china/.Group T. China Payment Systems. 2022.
Accessed 11 October 2022. Available:https://tenbagroup.com/all-you-need-to-know-about-mobile-china-paym ent-systems/.
Sun S, Law R, Schuckert M. Mediating effects of attitude, subjective norms and perceived behavioural control for mobile payment-based hotel reservations. International Journal of Hospitality Management. 2020;84.
Montag C. (2022). The Multipurpose Application WeChat. 2022. Accessed 23 June 2022. Available:https://www.frontiersin.org/ articles/ 10.3389/fpsyg. 2018.02247/full.
Rapyd. Asian Pacific Ecommerce Guideline 2020. 2020. Accessed 1 December 2022. Available:https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/5246303/Asia.pdf.
Chevalier S. List of e-wallets in India. 2022.
Accessed 2 January 2023. Available:https://www.statista.com/statistics/1187228/most-popular-payment-methods-online-shopping-colombia, addendum=.
PlayStore. Alipay Store. 2022.
Accessed 3 October 2022. Available:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id= com.eg.android.AlipayGphone.
Sun Y, Xue W, Bandyopadhyay S, Cheng D. Wechat mobile-payment-based smart retail customer experience: an integrated frame- work. Information Technology and Management. 2022;23(2):77-94.
PlayStore. OVO Store; 2022.
Accessed 2 January 2023. Available:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=ovo.id&hl=en&gl=US.
Statista. Number of Registered Users. 2021. Available: https://www.statista.com/statistics/ 12459 99/paypay-number-registered-users/
Chang W, Chen LM, Hashimoto T.Cashless Japan: Unlocking influential risk on mobile payment service. Information Systems Frontiers. 2021:1-14.
Panda I. Kakao Pay System in the Korean. 2022. Accessed 1 June 2022. Available: https://ivypanda.com/ essays/kakao-pay-system-in-the-korean-market/.
Lin X, Wu R, Lim YT, Han J Chen SC. Understanding the sustainable usage intention of mobile payment technology in korea: Cross-countries comparison of Chinese and Korean users. Sustainability. 2019;11(19).
Slotta D. Most Used E-wallets Among Respondents in Taiwan;2020.
Accessed 12 June 2023
Available:https://www.statista.com/statistics/ 1134038/ taiwan-most-used-mobile-payment-apps/
Hashim NAAN, NZulkiffli WFW, Aziz RC, Nawi NMM, Awang Z, Muhammad NH Yusoff AM. Grab pay app: the factors influencing tourists behavioural intention-to-use. Talent Development & Excellence; 2020.
P. Thailand. Reach More Thailand Customers with True Money. 2022. Available: https://e-ghl.com/reach-more-thailand-customers-with-truemoney-wallet/ payment/
PlayStore. True Money; Apps on Google Play; 2022.
Accessed 7 January 2023. Available:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=th.co.truemoney.wallet.
Digital D. Malaysia Mobile PaymentUsers 2025. 2023.
Accessed 4 January 2023. Available:https://www. docomodigital.com/ newsroom/vtc-pay-to-further-scale-mobile-commerce-in-vietnam/.
The Paypers. ShopeePay and DragonPay on Partnership. 2021. Accessed 4 June 2023. Available:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vtc.paygate.
Capterra. Dragonpay Reviews; 2022. Accessed 3 April 2023. Available:https://www.capterra.com/p/23325/ Dragonpay/reviews/.
Leonard S. Ecocash. 2017.
Accessed 8 May 2023. Available:https://www.techzim.co.zw/2017/1/ ecocash-processed-21-billion-since-launch/.
Leonard S. Ecocash Transactional Limits. 2022.
Accessed 19 May 2023. Available:https://www.263chat.com/ ecocash-transaction-limits-reviewed/.
Leonard S. Ecocash. 2022
Accessed 12 June 2023. Available:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EcoCash#cite note-Six-7
McNutt H. Digital Cash Transfer in Liberia. Strategic Impact Advisors.2016.
Akintaro S. Top 10 Fintech Apps in Nigeria by Number of Downloads as of January 2023. 2023.Accessed 18 April 2023. Available:https://nairametrics.com/.
Swiecka B, Terefenko BP, Paprotny D. Transaction factors influence on the choice of payment by polish consumers. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. 2021; 58(2).
Fan J, Shao M, Li Y, Huang X. Understanding users’ attitude toward mobile payment use: A comparative study between China and the USA. Industrial Management & Data System. 2018;113(3):524-540.
Petrova K. Mobile payment: Towards a customer-centric model. In International Conference on Web Information Systems Engineering. New Zealand. (In Press); 2008.
Choi H, Park J, Kim J, Jung Y. Consumer preferences of attributes of mobile payment services in South Korea. Telematics and Informatics. 2020;51.
Quach TN, Thaichon P. Effects of the triadic relationship among cus- tomers, service providers and the government on brand loyalty in mobile telecommunications industry. 4th International Conference on Global Business Environment. Bangkok Thailand. 2014 :(in press)
Ahmed W, Rasool A, Javed AR, Kumar AR, Gadekallu N, Jalil TR, Kryvinska Z. Security in next generation mobile payment systems: A comprehensive survey. IEEE Access. 2021;9:115932-115950.
Yeh H. Factors in the ecosystem of mobile payment affecting its use: From the customers perspective in Taiwan. Journal of theoretical and applied electronic commerce research. 2020; 15:13-29.
Dennehy D, Sammon D. Trends in mobile payments research: A literature review. Journal of Innovation Management. 2015; 3(1):49-61.
Gannamaneni A, Lyytinen K. A post-failure analysis of mobile payment platforms. In 2015 48th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. USA. 2015: (in press).
Eriksson N, G¨okhan A, Stenius M. A qualitative study of consumer resistance to mobile payments for in-store purchases. Procedia Computer Science. 2021;182:634-641.
Obidat A, Almahameed A, Alalwan M. An empirical examination of factors affecting the post-adoption stage of mobile wallets by consumers: A perspective from a developing country. Decision Science Letters. 2022; 11(3):273-288.
Handarkho YD, Harjoseputro Y. Intention to adopt mobile payment in physical stores: Individual switching behavior perspective based on push–pull–mooring (ppm) theory. Journal of Enterprise Information Management. 2019;33(2).
Rosnidah I, Muna A, Musyaffi A, Siregar N. Critical Factor of Mobile Payment Acceptance in Millennial Generation: Study on the UTAUT model. Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research. 2019;306:123-127.
Kim C, Galliers RD, Shin N, Ryoo JH, Kim J. Factors influencing internet shopping value and customer repurchase intention. Electronic commerce research and applications. 2012; 11(4):374-387.
Goyal K, Kar AK. Assessing service quality factors in mobile payments-insights based on user experiences in social media. Proceedings of ICETIT. 2019;605:743-753.
Su P, L. Wang L, Yan J. How users’ internet experience affects the adoption of mobile payment: a mediation model. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2018; (30(2):186-197.
Meli SD, Djoumessi YF, Djiogap CF. Analysis of the socio-economic determinants of mobile money adoption and use in Cameroon. Telecommunications Policy. 2022;46 (9).
Shao Z, Zhang L, Li X, Guo Y. Antecedents of trust and continuance intention in mobile payment platforms: The moderating effect of gender. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications. 2019; 33.
Norman SM, Avolio BJ, Luthans F. The impact of positivity and transparency on trust in leaders and their perceived effectiveness. The leadership quarterly. 2010;21(3):350-364.
Joseph-NG PS, Al-Rawahi MMK, Eaw HC. Provoking actual mobile payment use in the Middle East. Applied System Innovation. 2022;5(2).
Shankar A, Datta B. Factors affecting mobile payment adoption intention: An Indian perspective. Global Business Review. 2018;19(3):72-89.
Singh AK, Singh MP. Exploring influencing factors for m-payment apps uses in the Indian context. Innovations in Information and Communication Technologies (IICT-2020). 2020: 171–180.
Zixin T, Siyu H, Fei LW,, Mamun AA Adoption of cashless payment practices among malaysian millennials. Proceedings of International Conference on Emerging Technologies and Intelligent Systems. 2021;299:455-468.
Asuquo P. A Decentralised and Context-Aware Trust Management Scheme for Resource-Constrained Emergency Communications. University of Surrey; United Kingdom: 2018.
Gao L, Waechter KA. Examining the role of initial trust in user adoption of mobile payment services: an empirical investigation. Information Systems Frontiers. 2017; 19(3):525-548.
Zhu B, Charoennan W, Embalzado H. The influence of perceived risks on millennials’ intention to use m-payment for mobile shopping in Bangkok. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management. 2021;50(4).
Carstens M, Ungerer M, Human G. Perceived risk, trust and familiarity of online multisided pure-play platforms selling physical offerings in an emerging market. Southern African Business Review. 2019;23(1).
Ma L, Su X, Yu Y, Wang C, Lin K, Lin M. What drives the use of m-payment? an empirical study about alipay and wechat payment. In 2018 15th International Conference on Service Systems and Service Management (ICSSSM). China. 2018: (in press).
Nguyen L, Gallery G, Newton C. The joint influence of financial risk perception and risk tolerance on individual investment decision-making. Accounting & Finance. 2019; 59:747-771.
Venkatesh V, Thong JY, Xu X. Consumer acceptance and use of information technology: extending the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology. MIS quarterly. 2012; 36(1):157-178.
Kuo RZ. Why do people switch mobile payment service platforms? An empirical study in Taiwan. Technology in Society. 2020; 62.
Fatima T, Kashif S, Kamran M, Awan TM. Examining factors influencing adoption of m-payment: extending UTAUT with perceived value. International Journal of Innovation, Creativity, and Change. 2021;15(8): 276-299.
Webb H, Liu S, Yan MR. Evaluation of m-payment technology and sectoral system innovation: a comparative study of UK and Indian models. Electronics. 2019;8(11).
Wei MF, Luh YH, Huang YH, Chang YC. Young generation’s mobile payment adoption behaviour: Analysis based on an extended utaut model. Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research. 2021;16(4):618-637.
Mutahar AM, Daud NM, Turasamy NM, Isaac O, Abdulsalam R. “The mediating of perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use: the case of mobile banking in yemen. International Journal of Technology Diffusion (IJTD). 2018;9(2):21-40.
Abegao Neto FL, Figueiredo JCBd. Effects of age and income moderation on adoption of mobile payments in Brazil. Innovation & Management Review. 2022: 2515-8961.
Chawla D, Joshi H. The moderating role of gender and age in the adoption of mobile wallet. Foresight. 2020; 22(4):483-504.
Song K, Wu P, Zou, S. The adoption and use of mobile payment: Determinants and relationship with bank access. China Economic Review. 2023;77.
Leong CM, Tan KL, Puah CH, Chong SM. Predicting mobile network operators users m-payment intention. European Business Review, 2020;33(1).
Lwoga ET, Lwoga NB. User acceptance of mobile payment: the effects of user-centric security, system characteristics and gender. The Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries. 2017;81(1):1-24.
Stephen BU, Ozuomba S, Eyibo IE. Development of reward mechanism for proxy marketers engaged in e-commerce platforms. European Journal of Engineering and Technology Research. 2018;3(10):45-52.
Lu J, Liu C, Wei J. How important are enjoyment and mobility for mobile applications. Journal of Computer Information Systems. 2017;57(1):1-12.
Baabdullah AM. Factors influencing adoption of mobile social network games (m-sngs): The role of awareness. Information Systems Frontiers. 2020;22(2):411-427.
Singh SR. Srivastava R. Predicting the intention to use mobile banking in India. International Journal of Bank Marketing; 2018.
Islam MS, Karia N, Khaleel M, Fauzi FBA, Soliman MSM, Khalid J, Bhuiyan MYA, Mamun MAA. Intention to adopt mobile banking in Bangladesh: An empirical study of emerging economy. International Journal of Business Information Systems. 2019;31(1):136-151.
Alm KH, Chotiyaputta V, Bejrakashem S. Factors influencing mobile payment adoption by silver generation in Thailand and Sweden. Social Science Asia. 2022;8(2);22-44.
Dias SV, Mamun AA, Alam MK, Zainol NR. Predicting the adoption of mobile banking practices among Bangladeshi millennials. In International Conference on Emerging Technologies and Intelligent Systems. 2021: (in press).
Emara N, Said AEl. Financial inclusion and economic growth: The role of governance in selected mena countries. International Review of Economics & Finance. 2021;75:34-54.
Clarke R. Research opportunities in the regulatory aspects of electronic markets,” Electronic Markets. 2022; 32(1):179-200.
Greenacre J. Regulating mobile money: a functional approach. Pathways for Prosperity Commission Background Paper Series. 2018;4.
Kasiyanto S. Security issues of new innovative payments and their regulatory challenges. Bitcoin and Mobile Payments. 2016:145-179.
Xia H, Wang Y, Gauthier J, Zhang JZ. Knowledge graph of mobile payment platforms based on deep learning: Risk analysis and policy implications. Expert Systems with Applications. 2022;208.
Cervone E. M-payments: How much regulation is appropriate? Learning from the global experience. Bitcoin and Mobile Payments. 2016:121-142.
Teng S, Khong KW. Examining actual consumer usage of e-wallet: A case study of big data analytics. Computers in Human Behaviour. 2021;121.
Chaurasia SS, Verma S, Singh V. Exploring the intention to use m- payment in India: Role of extrinsic motivation, intrinsic motivation and perceived demonetization regulation. Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy. 2019;13(3-4).
Ezechukwu NV. Regulating innovation for financial inclusion: Lessons from Nigeria. Journal of African Law. 2021;65(3):431-459.
Lee S, Seo Y. Exploring how interest groups affect regulation and innovation based on the two-level games: The case of regulatory sandboxes in Korea. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2022;183.
Guo J, Bouwman H. An analytical framework for an m-payment ecosystem: A merchant’s perspective. Telecommunications Policy. 2016;40(2-3):147-167.
Altounjy R, Alaeddin O, Hussain HI, Sebastian K. Moving from bricks to clicks: Merchants acceptance of the mobile payment in Malaysia. International Journal of eBusiness and eGovernment Studies. 2020;12(2):136-150.
Moghavvemi S, Mei TX, Phoong SW, Phoong SY. Drivers and barriers of mobile payment adoption: Malaysian merchants’ perspective. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. 2021;59.
Wenner G, Bram JT, Marino M. Obeysekare, E., Mehta, K. Organizational models of mobile payment systems in low-resource environments. Information Technology for Development. 2018; 24(4): 681-705.
Franque FB, Oliveira T, Tam C. Continuance intention of mobile payment: TTF model with Trust in an African context. Information Systems Frontiers. 2023; 25(2):775-793.
Paas LJ, Eijdenberg EL, Masurel E. Adoption of services and apps on mobile phones by micro-entrepreneurs in Sub-Saharan Africa. International Journal of Market Research. 2021;63(1): 27-42.
Akinyemi BE, Mushunje A. Determinants of mobile money technology adoption in rural areas of Africa. Cogent Social Sciences. 2020; 6(1): 1815963.
Bassolé D, Koala G, Traoré Y, Sié O. Vulnerability analysis in mobile banking and payment applications on android in African Countries. In Innovations and Interdisciplinary Solutions for Underserved Areas: 4th EAI International Conference, InterSol 2020, Nairobi, Kenya. March 8-9, 2020; 4: 64-175. Springer International Publishing.
Thusi P, Maduku D K. South African millennials’ acceptance and use of retail mobile banking apps: An integrated perspective. Computers in Human Behavior. 2020;111:106405.
Eksteen C, Humbani M. Understanding proximity mobile payments adoption in South Africa: a perceived risk perspective. Journal of Marketing and Consumer Behaviour in Emerging Markets. 2021; 2(13): 4-21.
Cavallari M, Tornieri F. Vulnerabilities of Smartphones Payment Apps: The Relevance in Developing Countries. International Journal of the Academic Business World. 2017;11(1):1-14.
Wiese M, Humbani M. Exploring technology readiness for mobile payment app users. The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research. 2020;30(2):123-142.
Humbani M, Wiese M. An integrated framework for the adoption and continuance intention to use mobile payment apps. International Journal of Bank Marketing. 2019; 37(2):646-664.
Omotosho BS. Analysing user experience of mobile banking applications in Nigeria: A text mining approach. CBN Journal of Applied Statistics. 2021; 12(1):77-108.
Boateng R, Afeti EY, Afful-Dadzie E. Adoption of mobile payments in Ghana: A merchant perspective. 2019.
Abebe F, Lessa L. Factors affecting mobile payment adoption by merchants in Ethiopia. 2020.
Tabiaa M, Madani A. Analyzing the Voice of Customer through online user reviews using LDA: Case of Moroccan mobile banking applications. International Journal. 2021;10(1).
Badran MF. Socioeconomic dynamics in mobile money services in Egypt: An empirical analysis. Eurasian Business Review. 2017;7(2):267 -285.
Abdennebi HB. M-banking adoption from the developing countries perspective: A mediated model. Digital Business; 2023.